Rotten Residents and Rising Royals

Once the British had successfully conquered Java in 1811 they were left with an enormous island to run, and a serious problem with manpower.  The invasion itself might have been a grand project, but after the troop ships departed in October 1811 the new British colony was left with a skeleton crew.  Just as in the bad old days of the VOC, men with questionable qualifications were pressed into purposeful roles.  The Dutch had run Java through a series of residents in different districts, under who were subdivisions of local regents.  Despite the strident anti-Dutch propaganda that had accompanied the invasion – with its talk of misrule and corruption – so severe was the shortage of staff that leaving many of these original administrators in place was Raffles’ only option.  Over the early months of British rule detailed reports were called in from these far-flung Dutchmen, sweating in their crumbling bungalows all over Java.

Grovelers and groaners

Outpost: lonely Dutch residencies such as Salatiga were scattered across Java
Outpost: lonely Dutch residencies such as Salatiga were scattered across Java

The residential reports give an amusing glimpse of the gamut of attitudes and emotions amongst the Dutch at the British takeover.  Some were upright but apologetic.  The newly appointed resident of Karawang, a man by the name of W. Offers, bemoaned the state of the territory he had recently inherited – the roads were so bad “that it was impossible to go even on horseback from one Regency to another in the Rainy Season”.  He was eager to stress, however, that none of this was his fault, and he gave assurances of the district’s potential.

Other residents – like the head of the Eastern Districts, van Middelkoop – sent in reports brim full of recommendations.  There was no beseeching; only sober recommendations for administrative changes, lists of the superfluities that could be cut and the gaps that should be plugged, and a faint hint of disproval at these ignorant incomers.  Other reports, like that of Engelhard the Yogyakarta resident, were awash with worldly weariness.

Still other Dutch residents abandoned all dignity in their fawning desperation to cling to their jobs under the new management.  The Cirebon resident, Matthias Waterloo (who had previously been based at Yogyakarta), abased himself before the mighty British in his grovelling report, declaring his “readiness to shake off a yoke which had become unsupportable” and heartily recommending himself and his family to British protection.  “No Hollander ever will be a Frenchman”, he declared.  However, he was obviously as terrified of being judged a traitor to his own flag by the British for throwing himself so fully on their mercy as he was of the prospect of unemployment: “It is not to serve an enemy to my mother country that has induced me to enter into the service of the British Government, by no means” he simpered; “I can declare with the most sacred truth that I never would have thought of it if I still had been under the Dutch Government”.  It was all the fault of those terrible Frenchmen!  He went on labouring this point for two whole pages.

Waterloo was also eager to stress the prospects of his district.  “Wheat and all sorts of vegetables and fruits of the earth… would grow luxuriously if there were only persons here who had a sufficient knowledge of the mode of growing them,” he breathlessly declared.  The problem, of course, was the natives: “The Javan of Cheribon is very lazy and in the highest degree superstitious a slave to his ancient customs and therefore very difficult to reason with.  Timid and effeminate, there is no such thing as spirit or enterprise…”

In truth, the economic failure of Java had a great deal more to do with Dutch methods than some fatal flaw in “the native character”.  By the turn of the 19th century their empire under the aegis of the VOC had been in a state of terminal decline.  Meanwhile, as quasi-commercial colonialism went to seed, the Javanese had been quietly reasserting their glittering pre-eminence in the green heartlands of Central Java.  By the time Raffles arrived, Yogyakarta was a truly great town.

Return to glory

The Javanese royals who had presided over the chaos of late-Mataram, and who had seen the partition of the kingdom, had passed away into the realm of spirits, and towards the end of the 18th century a new generation of aristocrats had taken control of the courts.  These were the men who would be on the various thrones when the British arrived in Java, and while their fathers – by studiously ignoring each other, and making sure that they were never required to meet in person – had managed to bring a certain legitimacy to the divided kingdom, the younger men would look to test both the clauses of the Giyanti Treaty, and the resolve of the Dutchmen.

Sun of Kings: Hamengkubuwono II

The second post-partition Susuhunan of Surakarta ascended to the throne in 1788, and almost immediately came close to provoking a major confrontation with both the VOC and the rival Javanese courts.  The second Sultan of Yogyakarta, meanwhile, was crowned in 1792.  He had already rebelled against his aging father, overseen the erection of a grand curtain wall, 45 feet high and three miles long, ringing the entire Kraton including the Taman Sari and attendant quarters, and had written a mystical text entitled the Book of the Sun of Kings in which Mataram was reunited and the European colonialists in Java were annihilated by the combined forces of God, the Queen of the Southern Ocean, and a righteous – and decidedly autobiographical – prince.  If the officials of the Dutch VOC hadn’t been so drunk, decrepit and depressed they would probably have been worried.

Forts and failure

19 java
Glittering: Yogyakarta was a refined city by the time the British arrived

By this time, however, the VOC was on its very last legs.  Throughout Mangkubumi’s illustrious reign as Sultan the Dutch had never really managed to get the measure of Yogyakarta (the first Sultan’s “most notable physical trait”, it was recorded, “was the habit of answering importunate Dutch requests with an enigmatic smile”), and even once his somewhat less illustrious son took over they struggled to understand, let alone orchestrate, events inside the Kraton.  They had built a fine official residence on the northern edge of the Alun-Alun and had installed a European official as representative at the court, but their attempts to build a small fortress just to the east of the residency had turned into a farce.  Through corruption, incompetence and prevarication the project took decades.  Ground had been broken in 1764, but 16 years later the then resident reported that the work had “made little progress”.  Over the next decade a succession of Residents sent reassuring letters to Batavia, promising that the fort was “nearly ready”, but in 1790, more than 25 years after Mangkubumi had sanctioned the project (and after the Javanese themselves had managed to fortify their entire Kraton in a matter of weeks), it was only “very near completion”.  In fact it is by no means clear if it was ever really finished, or if the little Dutch garrison had actually properly moved in by the time the British arrived in Java.

The Dutch had a little more control over the court in Surakarta, but the list of late 18th Century Residents there amounted to a procession of the corrupt, the crooked and the conniving.  Incredibly, the position of Dutch Resident at Surakarta was unpaid, yet through pilfering from the treaty-sanctioned collection of birds’ nests for the soup trade, through extorting money from minor princes and even from the Susuhunan himself, and through pocketing transport tolls and business duties, the Residents accrued enormous black fortunes.  They also generated a great deal of hostility.  At least one of them seems to have been poisoned for his efforts.

This then, was the state of the royal Javanese world, and the role of Europeans within it, at the start of the second decade of the 19th Century; these were the courts and the kings who, in the words of one rather romantic British observer, constituted the “the Pith, the Sinews, and the Strength of Java”, and these were the men that Raffles was determined to dominate…

© Tim Hannigan 2013


16 responses to “Rotten Residents and Rising Royals

  1. My 4x grea tgrandfather Lt Col. George McGregor arrived in Batavia in Oct 1812 to July 1815 as Commander of the Eastern Division of the British forces in Java. In his journals he contrasts the Dutch and British behavior with the natives. In Sept 1814 he is presented with his wife Christina at the Court of the Emperor of Java. He describes the etiquette, customs and dress, tiger and leopard fights.

  2. How fascinating, Lorna! I would have loved to have seen those journals while working on the book. The man the British called the “Emperor of Java” was the Susuhunan of Surakarta. The Surakarta court still exists today, and a Susuhunan still rules from there today. Have you visited Java yourself to trace great-grandfather George’s footsteps?

    • My cousin Wm Blott has transcribed the Journals and they are published under the title Soldier and Sightseer in Java and Bengal. The Journals of Lt Colonel George MacGregor C.B.1780-1828 ISBN 0-9731532-0-2 I visited Bali before I had read the journals but our intention is to return and visit as we are visiting his trip route as he left Scotland for the last time. If you are unable to access the Journals let me know and I will try and get one to you. At the least I can send the list of the contents They are fascinating as they are not just military journals but rather observations of the world around him. Including not a very good opinion of Raffles!

      • Lorna, those journals look like an absolutely fabulous resource – I’m ever so frustrated that I didn’t know of them before the book was finished!

        Retracing MacGregor’s footsteps in Java will be a fantastic experience. Do let me know when you’re heading that way, should you need any tips or pointers.

      • Lenard Milich

        I would so like to read this, Lorna. I’ve lived in Indonesia for the past 17 years…. Have you made it to Java to follow in his footsteps?

      • I’m almost finished reading my paperback copy of Soldier and Sightseer in Java and Bengal, which originally belonged to a fellow named “Ian” and signed by Wm. Blott. I’m asking 200,000Rp plus postage from Oakville Ontario,

        a copy on recently sold for 1,500,000Rp

      • Lenard Milich

        Yes, please, Michael. If we move reasonably quickly, you could mail it to the other CA – the one in the US. A friend’s coming here mid-month. lmilich @ yahoo .com please!

  3. I picked up a copy of Soldier and Sightseer in Java and Bengal. and have been telling my friends from Indonesia about it, It seems, that the works of Raffles is taught in the school system there, and the corpse smell flower in Bogor, is named after him. Rafflesia Arnoldi

  4. Lenard Moloch. I am in jakarta Tebet Utara. With your copy. I left my local phone number on your and wifes Facebook profiles but heard nothing in 2 weeks. You must be on holidays. I am returning to Canada soon

  5. Hello to all of you. This is a very hard book to find. I am an historical novelist currently involved in research on the British Interregnum in Java, and an old Indonesia hand, myself. I would pay a pretty penny to lay hands on these journals. If anyone has one to sell please let me know at

    • Hello Dwight, the copy I took to Jakarta for Larry Milich has never been picked up and I will have it returned back to Canada in March if your interested Let me know what your pretty penny is also check the price on Amazon

    • Also be sure to check the journals of Lt Col. George MacGregor. Commander of the regimentime 59th Foot..1780 1828..soldier and sightseer in Java ISBN 9731532 -0-2.

      HE LANDED in Batavia Oct 1 1812 and sailed for Bengal July 1815. In Aug 1813 he was sent in command of an expedition against the Sultan of Palimbang and having deposed him returned to Java in Oct. He commanded the 59th at Makasser in Celebs June 1814. He was placed in command of the Eastern Division of the Army until on orders of Genl Nightingale the regiment was ordered to Bengal.
      His original journals are in our familes possession . He is my 3x great grandfather.

    • Be sure to get a copy of Lt Col.. George Mac Gregor journals A SOLDIER AND SIGHTSEER IN JAVA. HE took Command of the 59th Regiment when he arrived in Oct 1812. In Aug 1813 he was sent in command of an expedition against the Sultan of Palimbang and having deposedinner him returned to Java in Oct in 1814 he said to Bali and Celebration and commands the Regiment at Macasser on June 7 1813 where they carried out the assault on palace and town of the Raja Boni.
      On return to Java he was in command of the Eastern Division of the Army until being ordered to Bengal in July 1815.

    • I’m delighted to see that this obscure little blog post has served to put various people with interests in – and interesting things to share about – the British Interregnum in touch. Hope you all get your hands on the materials you need.
      You might also find the following interesting, a piece by the excellent Farish A Noor on another little-known related document:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s